Skip to main content

Message Guidance

The antisemitism machine creating smoke.

Smokescreen Antisemitism

In a smokescreen antisemitism strategy, politicians and political movements use antisemitism to increase racialized fear and division in order to gain supporters and win elections. This is a key component of their power strategy, but it could lead to being branded an antisemite, which could become a political liability. They need cover for this strategic use of antisemitism—it’s too powerful a tool and too central to their ideology to give up entirely. So the second step of the smokescreen antisemitism strategy is to create confusion by pointing the finger at progressives, people of color, and Muslims for antisemitism while claiming to be the true defenders of Jews.

Sometimes these accusations are completely false, and sometimes they are true or based on some truth. But smokescreen antisemitism accusations are always initiated with the intent to obscure the user’s own responsibility for using antisemitism for political gain. This is still true even when some people joining in on the accusation of antisemitism don’t intend to do this. All of these effects are harmful and it is useful to identify and name smokescreen antisemitism when it is used, even if an accusation warrants apology and steps toward repair.

Polluting our Society

It’s one thing to understand how antisemitism works and who benefits from it on a systemic level. But we often encounter antisemitism on an interpersonal level, and these experiences may or may not line up with our systemic understanding.

This is not only true about antisemitism: people growing up in unjust and inequitable societies often say and do things that reinforce those inequities and injustices, whether they themselves benefit from that system or not. This is sometimes born of ignorance, mistakes, or lack of exposure rather than malice, but that doesn’t make it less hurtful to experience.

Antisemitism is pervasive in our society. But using the harmful “water” and “virus” metaphors to express this can make it seem inevitable and unstoppable. Instead, think of antisemitic biases, stereotypes, and tropes like the pollution coming out of the machinery of division and fear. Noxious stories about Jews have been pumped into our society for generations—we don’t always notice them but we’ve all been exposed, and we’ve all internalized them to varying degrees. And the more we’re exposed, the more likely we are to accept these polluting stories as reality and to repeat them.

But, like pollution, there’s nothing natural or inevitable about it. And while it’s important to learn to recognize and avoid it, it’s even more important—and very clearly possible— to stop it at the source by shutting down the fear machine.

Talk about antisemitism as an OBJECT, but never as the ACTOR causing problems:

“Politicians who rely on division and fear for their power use antisemitism . . .”